COMPARATIVE WILDLIFE PROTECTION IN TÜRKİYE AND KAZAKHSTAN
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26577/JAPJ200411226Abstract
This study assesses the extent to which the wildlife, protected area and forest laws of Türkiye and Kazakhstan comply with the targets of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (KMGBF). Six laws were analyzed article by article: Hunting Law No. 4915, Law No. 2873 on National Parks and Forest Law No. 6831 in Türkiye; and the Law on Protection, Reproduction and Use of Animal World No. 593-II, the Law on Specially Protected Natural Areas No. 175-III and the Ecological Code No. 400-VI in Kazakhstan. A total of 179 substantive articles were scored on the 0–4 EFLD scale against four criteria derived from the KMGBF: sustainable wildlife management; hunting, trade and sustainable use; invasive alien species; and biodiversity and climate change. The articles were scored independently by two environmental and forest law experts: the author for the Turkish laws and Zh. B. Umbetbayeva for the Kazakh laws. A law is compliant with a criterion when its EFLD rate exceeds 50%. The Kazakh laws are compliant with the sustainable wildlife management criterion (55.9%), whereas the Turkish laws are not (37.9%). Hunting Law No. 4915 is the only law compliant with the hunting, trade and sustainable use criterion (57.7%). Neither country is compliant with the invasive alien species criterion (3.3% and 5.4%) or the biodiversity and climate change criterion (1.8% and 3.6%), and no article in either country scored 3 or 4 on the climate criterion. This is the first article-level, quantitative comparison of Turkish and Kazakh wildlife legislation of the KMGBF. It identifies the specific legal gaps that both countries need to close by 2030.
Keywords: wildlife law, hunting legislation, Global Biodiversity Framework, legal gap analysis, comparative law.










